Writing an Argument
一段好的论证只需要一个中心,但要把这个中心“撑住”,必须有四个部分。缺任何一块,读起来都会觉得空。
| 步骤 | 作用 | 常用句式 |
|---|---|---|
| 观点 | 一句话说清这一段要证明什么 | The strongest argument for X is… / X matters mainly because… |
| 解释 | 说明为什么这个观点成立 | This is because… / What this means in practice is… |
| 例子 | 给出具体、可验证的细节 | In 2023, for instance, … / A colleague of mine… |
| 回扣 | 把例子拉回论点 | That is why… / The point is not X but Y. |
Limiting private cars would improve public health more than any hospital policy. This is because traffic is the largest single source of PM2.5 in most Chinese cities, and fine particles are linked to asthma in children. In Beijing, when the city restricted cars on alternate days during the 2008 Olympics, hospital visits for respiratory problems fell by nearly a third in six weeks. Cleaner air is not a side effect of traffic policy; it is the main product.
注意最后一句的回扣方式:不是重复第一句,而是重新定义关系(“不是副作用,而是主要产物”)。
Reading the original paper is worth the extra hour. A summary tells you the conclusion but hides the conditions under which it holds. When the famous “power posing” study was reported, most articles said that standing confidently changes your hormones; the original paper, however, had eighteen participants and a failed replication three years later. Knowing that would have changed how you used the advice.
Remote work is efficient for execution and poor for invention. Efficiency needs quiet and focus; invention needs interruption. The ideas that turn into products usually begin as accidental conversations — someone overhears a problem at the next desk. A team that meets only on scheduled calls has removed the conditions for that accident.