免费英语学习资料库 · 精听 · 分级阅读 · 高频词汇 · 语法速查
中华英语网
Grammar · B1

定语从句:that / which / who 怎么选,逗号有没有区别

Relative Clauses

约 8 分钟 难度 B1 语法速查

一、先分清两种

限制性(无逗号)非限制性(有逗号)
作用限定“哪一个”,不可删补充说明,可删
关系词that / which / who / whom / whosewhich / who / whom / whose(不用 that)
例句The students who failed must retake the test.The students, who had all failed, were asked to retake the test.
含义只有没通过的那些学生所有学生都没通过

二、关系词选择三看

  1. 看先行词是人还是物:人用 who/whom,物用 which,人或物都可用 that(限制定语从句)。
  2. 看从句里缺什么成分:缺主语用 who/which/that;缺宾语用 who/whom/which/that,或直接省略;缺定语用 whose。
  3. 看有没有介词:介词后只能用 whom / which,不能用 that / who。the person to whom I spoke。

三、只能用 that 的四种情况

  • 先行词是 all / everything / nothing / anything:All that matters is the result.
  • 先行词被最高级或序数词修饰:the best book that I have read
  • 先行词既有人又有物:the people and places that I remember
  • 主句以 who / which 开头(避免重复):Who is the man that is standing there?

四、whose 与 of which

  • whose + 名词:the writer whose book won the prize(whose book = the book of whom)
  • of which 更正式:a theory the importance of which is hard to overstate

五、省略规则

限制性定语从句中,关系词作宾语时可以省略;作主语不能省。

  • ✓ The book (that) I bought yesterday is here.
  • ✗ The man (who) came late is my uncle. → who 不能省

六、写作提示

非限制性定语从句是提升句子层次最省力的工具,但一篇文章里不要超过三处,否则读起来像翻译腔:

The report, which was published last week, argues that the policy has failed. → 比两个短句更紧凑。